Blog Entry

BCS vs Playoff

Posted on: January 2, 2009 10:54 am

I guess I am a little tired of something that has been debated for the last few years.  I left it at the BCS is here and will never go away.  Then I read an article about why the BCS is better then a playoff.  His most intelligent comment in the article is that college football doesnt need a playoff because it makes the game better.   Then he went on to say what would teams have to play for if their was a playoff.  How about a playoff spot buddy.

Every sport has a playoff and you dont see them all upset that more teams have a shot at winning a NC with a playoff then they do without one.  We have all witnessed lower seeds in the NCAA, college world series, NFL come up roses winning their championships.  Thats right it is okay for an underdog to win a championship even though the BCS will wholeheartedly disagree as they fill their pockets with money.  We settle for championships based on biased coaches for their respective areas, harris interactive press as well, and finally we let computers help spill out who is playing for the NC.

Watching so many meaningless games the last couple weeks while sometimes entertaining really doesnt mean anything.  I am not going to waste my time showing how it is possible but taking conference champions from the major conferences and then adding a set amount wild cards from their you could easily have a 32 or 48 team tournament.  Yes we would be reduced to 10 game schedules which means the fordhams, citadels and toledos may miss out being crushed by some big 12 or sec foe but its not like they were going to win anyway.

This will also equalize recruiting a little more.  Players looking at college will know that they dont have to attend UF,OSU,Oklahoma, Texas,USC etc to see a NC game.  They have a better shot being in a playoff in a meaningful game and would have a shot at a national championship.  Could boise st, Utah, Ball st, Hawaii go through a 4 game playoff to win a championship?  Probably not because they would need more then one miracle to win but then again who knows what happens in that playoff with injuries or facing a certain team that overlooks them.  They would at least be playing for pride in their school. 

Bowl games would not be obsolete as 2 of the big bowls could host the semis followed a week later by the NC game.  Teams who are not in the semi's can be selected by all the rest of bowls.  Teams eliminated early can be selected by the heinken meinke car care bowls to play each other.  They still get their money for their conference and have a chance to finish the season on a winning note.  We would though in the longrun see one team with a winning streak of more then one game and that would be the NC.  I know its complicated but how much money these guys have in play with the BCS they can come up with a formula that would work.  The BCS would be decisive in deciding who that 32nd or 48th team would be.   Championships should be won on the field not through our current process. 

For all you people who like getting their blood pressure up by yelling why their team should be number 1 maybe your just scared what a playoff would show you.  USC fans can scream all day and night after their rose bowl victory they are number 1 because it makes them feel good.  Jan 9th we will have a national champion decided on the field by two teams placed their by the polls.  Yet their still could be 3 or 4 teams who could justify why they deserve to be the champion. 

Category: NCAAF
Tags: BCS

Since: Jun 10, 2010
Posted on: June 10, 2010 8:58 am

BCS vs Playoff

    "There needs to be a big playoff. We would do away with putting all this foolishness into the computer and hoping somehow it is going to do the right thing." -- Mike Leach, Texas Tech coach (and BYU alumnus) Coach Leach expresses the thoughts of so many college football viewers. There is a clear problem with the current BCS system and a change must be made to the playoffs. Plus, when the president of the United States is calling for a change, you know something must be done. The current system in place consists of a computer ranking system made up of different “Bowls”. Each bowl has different importance, but the only one that really matters is the BCS national championship. That means only two teams really get to play for something worthwhile. Controversy also arises when multiple teams of similar records and rankings are in contention for the national title but only two get chosen. However, this stupidity and anguish are unnecessary. Forget the “Little  Caesar’s Pizza Bowl”. A  playoff is the most fair system for determining the national champion. The question is how to implement it?

Since: Mar 27, 2010
Posted on: April 8, 2010 4:11 pm

BCS vs Playoff

What do you think, playoffs or BCS? Decide where you stand with our information, or debate where you stand with your peers. Find out what we think, or find out what Obama thinks! 

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or